Decision-making in action: How international-level professional football players gain an advantage

Understanding how both visual and contextual in-game information influences player’s attempts to gain advantage over their opponent is key to understanding skilled decision-making in fast-ball sports. In the present study, we conducted semi-structured interviews with 15 male professional football players to explore their reported behaviours and perspectives on their in-game decision-making and the ways in which they adapt to gain an advantage over their opponent. Professional players who have competed Internationally at either Under 17, Under 19, Under 21, or senior level took part in semi-structured interviews. The data were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis (Braun et al., 2016; Braun & Clarke, 2019) which generated four higher-order themes about players reported behaviours and perspectives on their decision-making and ways of gaining an advantage. These themes were: a) being “unpredictable”; b) option generating and invitation, comprising two sub-themes, generating and realising options, and acting on what invites you in the moment; c) anticipation and awareness; and d) dictating and controlling the game. A key finding was that players attempts to gain an advantage were largely grounded in the aim of ‘being unpredictable’ through the use of deception and disguise, as well as deliberate manipulation of action sequences in order to make their actions ‘hard to read’. A further important finding was that players do not always seek a universal optimal decision, as their individual action capabilities influence their available options. These findings have important implications for the assessment of decision-making performance in future empirical research.